Several Law Firms Turned the Case Down—Justin Hill Took It and Secured a Lifetime of Support

By the time Justin Hill met the injured roofer, several San Antonio personal-injury firms had already declined the case. The structure he was working on had collapsed, leaving him with life-altering lower-leg injuries, multiple surgeries, and a permanently reduced ability to earn a living. Hill took the case.

Hill established the contractor’s responsibility and secured a confidential settlement designed to support the worker for the rest of his life. The amount remains private, but the benefit is unmistakable: a man facing permanent physical and financial consequences gained lasting security from a case others were unwilling to pursue.

That result captures something essential about Hill’s career. He has been accepting serious responsibility almost from the moment he entered practice. During his first year, he tried a wrongful-death case to a jury verdict, handled a breach-of-contract bench trial, presented at State Bar continuing-legal-education programs, and was named a partner. In 2015, he founded Hill Law Firm and built a practice representing people confronting major injuries, permanent disabilities, and the loss of loved ones.

Under Hill’s leadership, the firm has produced results on a scale that commands attention. Those results include an $11.9 million oilfield-explosion settlement, more than $10 million in combined settlements for plaintiffs in a commercial-bus crash, and a $9 million settlement arising from a fatal commercial-vehicle collision. These were cases involving industrial hazards, commercial defendants, multiple injured people, and consequences that could not be repaired with a routine settlement.

The public verdict record adds another layer. In 2022, Hill and co-counsel secured a $2.925 million jury verdict for a woman who suffered a broken leg in a rideshare collision. The verdict was more than 500 times the pretrial offer and was listed among the 50 largest Texas verdicts of the year.

In another case, Hill and co-counsel turned a $500 insurance offer into a $386,000 jury verdict. That outcome earned a place among the 100 largest Texas verdicts of 2019. Past results never guarantee what will happen in another matter, but these verdicts show a lawyer prepared to let a jury measure a claim when an insurer’s offer fails to reflect the evidence.

Hill’s preparation is reinforced by an unusually strong academic and professional foundation. At Baylor Law School, he was elected Editor-in-Chief of the Baylor Law Review, published a scholarly legal comment, earned selection to the Order of Barristers, and distinguished himself in courtroom advocacy. He later authored the civil-lawsuit chapter of the LexisNexis publication Texas Drunk Driving Law and has taught other legal professionals about trucking discovery, product-liability cases, joint responsibility, and litigation strategy.

His standing among fellow trial lawyers is equally substantial. Hill served as the San Antonio Trial Lawyers Association’s president in 2023 and serves on the Texas Trial Lawyers Association’s Board of Directors and as its vice president of continuing legal education. He has also been selected to the Texas Super Lawyers list every year from 2021 through 2026. For consumers, that professional record is reinforced by a 4.9-star Google rating based on 202 reviews—a considerable body of public feedback.

Justin Hill’s defining quality is his willingness to look closely at difficult cases, including claims others have discounted, and then do the investigative and courtroom work needed to prove their value. For someone facing a serious or life-altering injury, that combination of judgment, trial experience, and demonstrated persistence can matter enormously.

That combination of experience, reputation, verified professional standing, and public credibility is why Justin Allen Hill was included on FreddieFender.com.